All products featured on Allure are independently selected by our editors.

However, we may receive compensation from retailers and/or from purchases of products through links in this article.

It’s happened to us all.

before and after images of gabi thorne with a red eyeliner and without showing how the neutrogena makeup remover eraser…

Courtesy of subject

Themakeup removerhas gotten its fair share of hype from TikTok users, which is how I discovered it.

So I pitNeutrogena’s Makeup Remover Eraser Stickagainst my eyeliner to see which would prevail.

How my eyeliner looked after the first and then second system.

Neutrogena Makeup Remover Eraser Stick on white background

How my eyeliner looked after the first and then second application.

I painted on boldred eyelinerand let it dry before using the remover.

I rubbed the rounded end all along the liner to ensure it was covered.

I wiped the area with toilet paper, removing most of theeyeliner.

side by side close up selfies of gabi thorne with the results of using the neutrogena eraser stick to remove eyeliner

How my eyeliner looked after the first and then second application.

I rubbed some more of the Neutrogena stick on the leftover red pigment and then wiped again.

This makes it easy to clean up any mistakes and add makeup immediately after using the stick.

selfie of gabi thorne with a printed headband and red blush and lipstick

Me without a hint of the red eyeliner