All products featured on Allure are independently selected by our editors.
However, we may receive compensation from retailers and/or from purchases of products through links in this article.
In this article:
Choosing between mineral, chemical, or hybrid formulas is where things can get complicated.
Getty
For years, the decision between different sunscreen types came down to a few straightforward pros and cons.
The deciding factors were determined by product texture, skin tone, and skin sensitivity.
Our sunscreen options have evolved considerably.
Getty
Mineral sunscreens, particularly when tinted or made with zinc nanoparticles, are now viable options for all complexions.
In other words, it was exploratory; not exhaustive.
Loretta, comes down as well.
What is mineral sunscreen?
There are just two mineral sunscreens active ingredients: zinc oxide and titanium dioxide, says Dr. Ciraldo.
These both work mainly by reflecting UV rays off of them before the rays penetrate into skin cells."
Plume Creative
Chemical sunscreen filters, known as organic sunscreen ingredients, are everything else."
One of the main arguments in favor of mineral sunscreens comes down to the fact that they are photostable.
This means that they do not have to be reapplied as frequently as chemical sunscreens when exposed to light.
As mentioned, past complaints regarding mineral sunscreen largely came down to cosmetic texture and appearance.
Luckily, innovation is changing the reputation and the usability of mineral sunscreens.
Tinted varieties usingblue-light-protectivezinc oxide provide additional options for darker skin or those seeking better cosmetic coverage.
Getty Images
What are the ingredients of chemical sunscreen?
When it comes to aesthetics, a chemical sunscreen is an easier sell.
(By the way, that acronym stands for “generally recognized as safe and effective.")
Aside from what is not yet known, chemical sunscreens do come with some downsides.
“This means you have to reapply [them] more diligently to get the best protection.”
What is hybrid sunscreen?
Hybrid formulas, which combine both mineral and chemical filters, provide a compelling case.
Dr. Ciraldo’s patients are “often most happy with a hybrid sunscreen,” she says.
What sunscreen ingredients are controversial and regulated by the FDA?
Still the new research on chemical actives shouldn’t necessarily be ignored.
They don’t know what the implications mean, but the bottom lineis to minimize chemicals.”
“Oxybenzone has [also] been linked to allergies, hormone-disruption via estrogenic activity, and cell damage.
“There are just so many potential problems with chemical [filters],” Dr. Hartman says.
Generally, minerals are the way to go.”
Koestline simply does not formulate with chemical filters.
“Chemical sunscreens are still questionable.”
Other experts fall somewhere in the middle, recommending some chemical filters but not others.
Otherwise, I continue to recommend the other approved chemical sunscreens like avobenzone and octocrylene."
Then there are the experts who prioritize using sunscreen rather than distinguishing between types.
Robinson agrees that finding a sunscreen of SPF 30 or higher for use every day is the priority.
So, chemical vs. mineral sunscreen: which should I buy?
The very fact that experts disagree proves that no singular opinion can make the final call just yet.
It also containssqualane, a hydrating ingredient derived from natural sugarcane; as well as cooling water lily.
Dr. Mehr recommendsBabyganics SPF 50 Sunscreen Lotion, which contains six percent zinc oxide and three percent titanium dioxide.
)Trader Joe’s Zinc Oxide Mineral Sunscreen Sprayis a quick way to douse yourself in SPF 30.
The dermatologist-developed, vegan sunscreen is non-comedogenic and water-resistant for up to 80 minutes.
The EltaMD UV Clear Broad-Spectrum SPF 46 is also a great pick for acne-prone skin.
It also contains glycerin for an additional boost of hydration.
The line’s mineral sunscreen,Physical Protectant Broad Spectrum SPF 45, provides a tinted alternative.
If you’d prefer a mineral blocker, they also created a mineral gel line,Clearly Zinq.
