Allureeditors leave no stoneor compact, palette, or tubeunturned when determining ourBest of Beauty Award winners.

What else does our seal symbolize?

We’re often asked “when” we start working on Best of Beauty.

Collage of Allure editors testing best of beauty products.

Bella Geraci

But the better question might be: When are wenotworking on it?

Our decisions don’t happen overnight or in one long meeting.

We know, we know: That sounds unbelievable.

Boxes piled up in beauty closet for testing Allure Best of Beauty Awards

Beauty closet associate Edward Horgan stand behind a mountain of boxes filled with products to test.

But we’ve got the receipts.

Mid-October 2023

We send out a call for the 2024 awards…

And brands answer.

We ask brands to submit any product, old or new, that they believe is contender.

Sarah Kinonen Organizing BoB Submissions in Closet

Associate beauty director Sarah Kinonen sorts Best of Beauty submissions while testing out a sun visor… indoors.

For 2024, we received a whopping 7,587 submissions.

We start organizing the submissionsexporting all the data, making spreadsheets…you know, the fun stuff.

This part is always exciting.

Makeup swatches on a hand

Senior beauty editor Nicola Dall’Asen.

Early November

We get really familiar with those spreadsheets.

Beauty closet associate Edward Horgan stand behind a mountain of boxes filled with products to test.

Mid- to End of November

Last call!

woman wearing face mask

Associate beauty director Sarah Kinonen

Brands have had about a month to submit, and we close our first round of submissions.

December

It’s time to get our Marie Kondo on.

Associate beauty director Sarah Kinonen sorts Best of Beauty submissions while testing out a sun visor… indoors.

Girl wearing skin care on face

Social media manager Bianca Richards

Senior beauty editor Nicola Dall’Asen.

For example, associate beauty editor Annie Blay (that’s me!)

signed up to testblow-dryer brushessolely to find a tool that would cut herwashdaysin half.

Woman wearing LED Hair Growth Mask

Senior beauty editor Jesa Marie Calaor

Spoiler: She found one and it won aBest of Beauty Award!

Sometimes we find new favorites in categories we weren’t even supposed to be testing.

End of March to mid-April

Did someone just put a two-hour meeting on my calendar?

Black girl blow drying hair

Associate beauty editor Annie Blay

Yes, yes they did.

Think of it as the ultimate beauty debate.

We eliminate products editors disliked and argue over the products that didn’t quite have a consensus.

End of March

Clean up, clean up, everybody clean up!

Spring

We’re getting closer!

The product has to have data in the form of clinical studies to back up its claims.

End of Spring

Yay!

But also, shh!

Summer

It’s a sprint to the finish line!

The work doesn’t stop here, though.

But, as you may have guessed, we’re not done yet.

October 19

Time to party!

And you’re invited!

Together, we all gather to celebrate another successful year of theAllureBest of Beauty Awards.

By the time you’re reading this, we’ve probably already sent out submission forms for next year.

So it begins again!